Entrepreneur Legal US · Insight
US IP Ownership Checklist for Startups
By Gabriel C. Mbanefo, Esq. — Attorney admitted to the New York State Bar and Solicitor of the Senior Courts of England and Wales; President, Law Offices of Gabriel C. Mbanefo, P.C. d/b/a Entrepreneur Legal.
IP ownership checklist at a glance
| IP job | Question to answer | Typical evidence / tool |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Who legally owns the asset now? | Employment records, founder transfer, contractor agreement, assignment. |
| Registration | Would filing create or strengthen protection? | USPTO patent/trademark filings; U.S. Copyright Office registration. |
| Confidentiality | Does value depend on secrecy? | NDA, confidentiality provisions, access controls, trade-secret measures. |
| Licensing | Should another party use the IP without owning it? | License defining scope, territory, field, term and restrictions. |
| Third-party rights | Does the asset include code, media or data the startup does not own? | Open-source/commercial licenses, stock terms, dataset/vendor rights. |
| Employee inventions | Are contractual assignment demands limited under relevant state law? | California/New York exceptions, notices, invention logs and signed agreements. |
| AI-assisted material | What human-created expression and tool-use permissions can be evidenced? | Prompts, outputs, edit history, human contribution records and provider licences. |
The founder problem: the company can build the product without cleanly owning it
A startup pays a freelance developer, a branding studio and a founding consultant. Everyone assumes the company owns the source code, interface, logo and launch content because the invoices were paid. During seed diligence, the investor asks for signed evidence of ownership. The company finds scopes of work and payment records but no clear assignments. That gap can affect financing, licensing and a later acquisition.
1. Build an IP asset register, with evidence for each creator
List core code, architecture, databases, brand assets, designs, content, inventions, domain rights, documentation and confidential know-how. For each asset, record its creator and employer/contractor status; whether it predates incorporation; current owner; signed transfer or licence; country of protection; registration; supplier or AI-tool dependencies; and the files proving the claim. Record exceptions and unresolved gaps, not just reassuring check marks.
2. Copyright: distinguish employee work, nine commissioned categories and assignments
Under 17 U.S.C. §§ 101 and 201, copyright normally starts with the author. There are two work-made-for-hire routes: (1) a work prepared by an employee within the scope of employment; or (2) a specially commissioned work that falls within one of nine specified statutory categories and is expressly designated as work made for hire in a signed written agreement. Freelance software development is not automatically in a commissioned category merely because an invoice or contract uses that label. State-law agency factors also matter when determining employee status.
Under 17 U.S.C. § 204(a), a copyright ownership transfer other than by operation of law generally needs a written instrument or memorandum signed by the rights owner or authorised agent. Payment, an invoice or possession of source files does not alone transfer copyright (see also 17 U.S.C. § 202). For contractors and agencies, obtain a clearly scoped present assignment where suitable; confirm rights in pre-existing tools and work of subcontractors. Written work-made-for-hire language and a fallback assignment serve distinct functions.
3. Employee inventions: check California and New York assignment limits
Employee-invention rights depend on the employment agreement and applicable state law. California Labor Code § 2870 generally excludes inventions made entirely on an employee’s own time without employer equipment, facilities, supplies or trade secrets, except for inventions connected with the employer’s business/research or arising from the employee’s work. Under § 2872, covered invention-assignment agreements must be accompanied by written notice of this statutory protection. New York Labor Law § 203-f similarly excludes qualifying own-time inventions and makes overbroad provisions unenforceable. These rules are examples, not national defaults; review governing law, job functions, invention history and notice records.
4. Patent rights: identify inventors, secure written transfers and record where appropriate
Patent rights initially arise through inventorship; inventorship is not the same as equity ownership or a managerial title. Identify every person who contributed to the conception of claimed inventions and trace written transfers. Under 35 U.S.C. § 261, patents, applications and interests therein may be assigned by an instrument in writing; recordation helps address competing purchasers and patent-office chain-of-title records. Review the scope, execution, territories, continuing assistance, prior assignments and filing status with patent counsel. Public disclosure can jeopardise foreign patent rights even where limited US exceptions may be available.
5. Trademarks: assign rights with goodwill and check intent-to-use restrictions
Registering a company name or domain does not automatically establish trademark ownership. Trademark rights arise from lawful source-identifying use and the relevant legal rules. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1060, a registered mark or application ordinarily transfers with the associated business goodwill through a duly executed written assignment. Certain intent-to-use applications generally cannot be assigned before qualifying use filings except to a successor to the relevant ongoing business. Check the mark, goods/services, goodwill, application status, effective date and USPTO recordation; clearance and priority remain separate questions.
6. Trade secrets: prove reasonable measures as well as ownership and control
The federal Defend Trade Secrets Act defines trade secrets by economic value from secrecy and reasonable steps to preserve it; state law can add other requirements. An NDA is helpful but does not replace access controls, restricted repositories, offboarding, supplier confidentiality duties, security procedures, and records of what was disclosed to whom. Keep a separate inventory of trade secrets and avoid promising that ordinary non-confidential know-how is necessarily protected.
7. Transfer or license pre-incorporation and founder-created IP expressly
Code, designs, trade names and inventions produced before company formation are not automatically transferred when an LLC or corporation is established. Identify each founder’s contributions, earlier employer or university claims, grants, collaborative work and open-source inputs. If the business needs ownership, execute an appropriate post-formation transfer or licence and reconcile it with founder equity, employment agreements and existing financing documents.
8. Test contractors, agencies and subcontractors through to the real creators
A contractor or agency cannot transfer better rights than it holds. Trace the actual creators and the agency’s authority to transfer their rights. Check subcontractor terms, individual contributor agreements, stock photos, fonts, contractor-developed components, exclusions for reusable tools, and licences that must continue after termination. Confirm whether warranties, delivery obligations and permitted sublicensing align with the product’s expected sale and commercial use.
9. Audit AI-assisted and AI-generated assets separately
Record every material AI-generated or AI-assisted output used in code, marketing, design or content. Preserve the prompt/output history where relevant, human-authored source material, substantial human edits or arrangements, and the AI provider’s terms on inputs, outputs, commercial use, confidentiality and training. The U.S. Copyright Office’s January 2025 Part 2 report explains that copyright may protect sufficiently human-authored expressive elements in an AI-assisted work, but not material generated solely by AI on the strength of prompts alone. Contractual permission to use an output is not the same as owning enforceable copyright in every element. Check third-party material embedded in outputs and record unresolved rights.
10. Examine open-source, datasets and third-party licence limitations
Create a software bill of materials and licence schedule identifying open-source components, their versions and obligations, including attribution, distribution and source-code conditions. Trace third-party content, fonts, stock media, training data and proprietary APIs to their licences, restrictions and sublicense rights. These are often permission questions, but defects in ownership or sublicensing chains can also undermine the startup’s legal ability to distribute, modify, train on or transfer an asset.
11. Separate copyright registration and recording from ownership
Copyright exists automatically in qualifying original works, but the registration process has litigation consequences. Under 17 U.S.C. § 411, registration or refusal is generally required to sue for infringement of a US work, subject to exceptions. Sections 412, 504 and 505 make timing relevant to statutory damages and fee recovery, subject to the statute’s exceptions. Copyright Office recordation, USPTO patent recordation and trademark recordation are distinct from forming an assignment; choose each filing based on the asset and transaction. Check deadlines and evidence before a financing or sale.
12. Keep chain-of-title evidence ready for diligence
| Diligence question | Evidence to produce |
|---|---|
| Who created the core code/content/design? | Employment records, contractor agreements, contributor history and assignments. |
| Does the company own it? | Signed chain-of-title documents and registration records. |
| What third-party components are used? | Open-source/commercial license inventory and material terms. |
| Is the brand protected? | Clearance work and USPTO filings/registrations where appropriate. |
| Are inventions documented? | Inventor records, assignments, disclosures and filing history. |
| Is confidential know-how controlled? | Access controls, NDAs, policies and disclosure records. |
| Do state employee-invention exclusions affect any assignment? | California § 2870/§ 2872 notices, New York § 203-f review, invention logs and employment agreements. |
| Are AI-assisted assets commercially usable and protectable? | Human authorship/edit logs, input/output provenance, vendor terms, third-party material audit. |
| Were registered patent/trademark transfers executed and recorded properly? | Signed right-specific assignments, goodwill/intent-to-use review, USPTO records and deadlines. |
Common IP ownership mistakes
| Mistake | Practical consequence |
|---|---|
| Assuming payment transfers contractor copyright | Company may not have clean title to key code or content. |
| Treating entity/domain registration as trademark protection | Brand may conflict with prior rights. |
| Using an NDA but no assignment | Confidentiality can exist while ownership remains with the creator. |
| Ignoring pre-incorporation founder IP | Core assets may remain personally owned. |
| Ignoring open-source/stock licenses | Company can make ownership warranties it cannot support. |
| Blanket employee invention assignment without state-law check | California or New York exclusions and notice obligations may limit enforcement. |
| Assuming AI output is automatically company-owned copyright | Insufficient human authorship or incompatible vendor/input terms may undermine protection/use. |
| Generic transfer for patent or trademark rights | Missing goodwill, application restrictions, inventorship or recordation may leave gaps. |
How StartWise® Drafting and an optional static template fit
StartWise® Drafting currently includes an IP Assignment Agreement for a routine identified transfer. You answer guided questions, generate a tailored first draft and review Drafting Notes, which can surface assumptions and completion points but are not legal advice or a comprehensive legal review. You remain responsible for verifying the asset, present owner, any third-party restrictions and the relevant execution or recordation requirements.
Prefer legal/IP advice where title is disputed, employee-invention exceptions apply, inventorship or patent strategy is unsettled, trademarks or registered rights need specific transfer mechanics, licences or AI/third-party inputs are complex, or assets are cross-border. A generic assignment document does not resolve those issues.
Prefer a static document instead? Entrepreneur Legal US offers an IP Assignment Agreement template for a straightforward US startup transfer on Etsy: Attorney-Drafted IP Assignment Agreement. A self-edited template does not identify the correct owner, solve chain-of-title problems or automatically satisfy patent/trademark formalities. Check the asset and transaction before choosing it.
Frequently asked questions
Does paying a freelancer automatically transfer copyright to my startup?
No. Contractor work is not automatically work made for hire. Specially commissioned work must fit one of the nine statutory categories and have a signed work-made-for-hire agreement; otherwise a signed copyright assignment is generally needed for transfer.
Do I need to register copyright?
Copyright generally arises automatically for eligible works. For a US work, registration or refusal is generally required before filing a federal infringement action, subject to statutory exceptions (17 U.S.C. § 411); the timing of registration may affect eligibility for statutory damages and attorneys’ fees (17 U.S.C. § 412).
Does forming an LLC or corporation transfer founder IP?
No. Formation by itself does not automatically transfer personally owned IP to the entity.
Is an NDA enough to own IP?
No. An NDA controls confidentiality and use. Ownership transfer requires assignment or other applicable transfer mechanics.
Can my startup require every employee to assign inventions made at home?
Not always. California Labor Code §§ 2870 and 2872 and New York Labor Law § 203-f limit certain own-time invention-assignment clauses. Exceptions and California notice obligations must be checked against the employment facts and governing law.
Does an IP assignment transfer a registered trademark or patent automatically?
The document and transaction need the correct statutory formalities. Patent transfers generally require a written instrument under 35 U.S.C. § 261; trademark assignments require executed writing and related goodwill, and intent-to-use applications have special restrictions under 15 U.S.C. § 1060. Recordation can matter.
Can StartWise® decide whether a trademark or patent is registrable?
No. StartWise® is guided drafting. Clearance, patentability and infringement analysis require separate legal/IP review.
Choose the right next step
Draft through StartWise. Review for less.
Explore the current guided US documents, or contact Entrepreneur Legal US where your matter requires review, consultation or bespoke support.
